What does a marketing strategy consultant actually do?

A marketing strategy consultant diagnoses the real growth bottlenecks in your business — not just your marketing channels. The work covers positioning (who you serve and why they should choose you), messaging (how you communicate that credibly), and system design (which channels and processes reliably generate the right leads). In 7 out of 10 cases, the root problem is not the marketing execution but a lack of positioning clarity.

How is marketing strategy consulting different from hiring a marketing agency?

An agency executes tasks: ads, content, SEO. A marketing strategy consultant defines what to execute and why — before money flows into channels. Strategy consulting makes sense when you already invest in marketing but results don't match the spend. Without a solid strategic foundation, even the best agency execution produces mediocre results.

When does marketing strategy consulting make sense for small businesses and SMEs?

Marketing strategy consulting makes sense for SMEs when: your marketing budget is not delivering proportional results, your company is growing but that growth feels chaotic and unpredictable, you are repositioning, launching a new product, or entering a new market, or you want to build a growth system that works without you personally driving every campaign.

How much does marketing strategy consulting cost?

Costs vary significantly depending on scope — from a single diagnostic session to a six-month growth system engagement. The honest calculation: poor consulting costs more than good consulting. You pay twice — once for the advice and once for the initiatives that deliver no results. The question is not what consulting costs but what the absence of a clear strategy costs you per quarter.

What are the most common reasons marketing strategies fail?

Three structural reasons account for most failures: (1) positioning is too broad — trying to serve everyone means being nobody's first choice; (2) marketing promises don't match internal reality — if your website signals premium but your sales process feels cheap, trust collapses; (3) you are measuring the wrong metrics — tracking clicks and followers instead of customer acquisition cost, lifetime value, and channel quality.

What results can I expect from marketing strategy consulting?

Simon Förstemann's clients have documented results including +74% revenue growth within 18 months on the same budget. The precondition: genuine clarity on positioning and a consistent growth system built on that foundation. Results depend on the starting point, the competitive environment, and how decisively recommendations are implemented.

Marketing Strategy Consulting: What It Delivers

Years Experience

Ventures Founded

+74%

Revenue Growth Documented

1:1

Always Personal

Marketing does not work in a vacuum. It only works when brand, message, and business structure are all pointing in the same direction. Marketing strategy consulting that ignores this — and only optimises channels and budgets — is solving the wrong problem.

Across fourteen years of business experience, six ventures founded, and dozens of consulting engagements, one pattern repeats itself: Marketing is rarely the real problem. The real problem is a lack of clarity about who the business truly serves and what makes it uniquely valuable.

Key Takeaways

— Marketing strategy consulting defines who you serve and why before any budget flows into channels — in 7 out of 10 cases the real bottleneck is unclear positioning, not weak execution.
— It differs from an agency: an agency executes ads, content and SEO, while a strategy consultant decides what to execute and why — working on positioning, messaging, and the growth system simultaneously.
— Cost depends on scope, from a single diagnostic session to a six-month growth-system engagement; poor consulting costs more because you pay twice — for the advice and for the initiatives that deliver nothing.
— With clear positioning and a consistent system, Simon Förstemann's clients have documented +74% revenue growth within 18 months on the same budget — drawing on 14 years, 6 ventures, and 1:1 work only.

Years in
Marketing & Brand

Ventures Founded, Each
Scaled to 7 Figures

74%

Revenue Growth in
18 Months, Same Budget

What Marketing Strategy Consulting Actually Means

Marketing strategy consulting does not mean building your next content calendar or running A/B tests on your ads. That is operational marketing work. Strategy is the question that comes before any of that:

The Defining Question Who exactly do we serve, what problem do we solve better than anyone else, and how do we build a system around that which grows reliably?

When that question is answered clearly, every operational initiative improves. When it is not answered, every budget gets wasted — regardless of how well the execution is carried out.

Serious marketing strategy consulting therefore works on three levels simultaneously:

Positioning: Who you are for, who you are not for, and what makes you the only logical choice for your target audience
Messaging: How you communicate that in a way that is immediately understood and believed
System: Which channels, formats, and processes build on that foundation and reliably generate growth

Why Most Marketing Strategies Fail

The most common mistake in marketing strategy consulting: starting with channels and tactics rather than with clarity. The result is a strategy that looks technically sound but produces nothing.

The Classic Pattern A small business or SME invests in SEO, paid social, or content marketing, sees early traction, then watches results plateau. They switch agencies. The same thing happens again. The problem was never the agency. It was the missing foundation underneath.

Three concrete reasons why marketing strategies do not work:

1. Positioning Is Too Broad

If you want to serve everyone, you are nobody's first choice. A marketing strategy can only function once a clear decision has been made about who you are optimising for. That decision automatically excludes others. That is the point.

2. Marketing and Business Reality Are Misaligned

If your marketing promises premium and your sales process feels cheap, trust never forms. If your website signals agility and your internal processes are rigid, customers feel the contradiction. Marketing that does not match internal reality destroys trust faster than it can build it.

3. You Are Measuring the Wrong Things

Most companies track clicks, followers, and impressions. The questions that actually matter are: What does it cost to acquire a customer? How long do they stay? Which channel delivers the highest-value clients? Without these answers, you are optimising in the wrong direction.

What a Rigorous Marketing Strategy Consulting Process Looks Like

Every engagement is different because every business is different. That said, there is a logic that has proven itself consistently:

Diagnosis: Where Do You Actually Stand?

Before any initiative is recommended, you need to understand where the real bottlenecks are. They are often not where you first look.

Sharpen Your Positioning

For whom are you the only logical choice? This question must be answered before a single euro or dollar flows into any channel.

Align Brand and Messaging

How does the business communicate externally? Is the message consistent? Does it build trust with the right audience?

Build the Growth System

Which channels, formats, and processes fit the positioning and reliably generate the right contacts? Operational work begins only here.

Measure and Iterate

Strategy is not a document. It is an ongoing process that adjusts based on real numbers and real market response.

What Good Marketing Strategy Consulting Costs

The honest answer: it depends on what is needed. A single diagnostic session is a different scope from a six-month engagement building a complete growth system.

What you can avoid: the cheap version that quickly recommends a list of initiatives without understanding the underlying business. Poor consulting costs more than good consulting — because you pay twice: once for the advice and once for the initiatives that deliver nothing.

My Approach Simon Förstemann works exclusively 1:1, with a limited number of clients at any one time. Not as a marketing device, but because depth is only possible when capacity is finite. That costs more than an agency. It also delivers more.

When Marketing Strategy Consulting Makes Sense

Not every business needs external marketing strategy consulting. It makes particular sense when:

You are already investing in marketing but results do not match the spend
Your business is growing but that growth feels chaotic and unpredictable
You want to build or reposition your brand and marketing from the ground up
As a founder, you no longer want to be the bottleneck — you need a system that runs without you driving every campaign
A market entry, new product launch, or new target audience is on the horizon

It does not make sense if you are primarily looking for someone to execute tasks. There are excellent agencies for that. Strategy is something different.

Why Simon Förstemann as Your Marketing Strategy Consultant

Simon Förstemann does not consult from a textbook. He has founded six companies, successfully exited two, built an international brand agency with offices in Berlin and Barcelona, and worked with clients including Continental, FLSK, and TenneT.

The difference from a consultant who has only ever consulted: Simon Förstemann knows the consequences of wrong decisions from direct personal experience. That changes the quality of every recommendation.

And the craft is there too. Red Dot Award, German Design Award, documented revenue growth across client engagements. Not as credentials on a wall, but as context for what gets brought to the table.

Initial Consultation

Ready for a marketing strategy that actually works?

In a free 30-minute introductory call, we look together at where the real bottlenecks in your marketing and brand are. No sales pitch. No generic proposal.

Book a Call →

30 minutes · free · no obligation · directly with Simon Förstemann

About the author

Simon Förstemann

Growth strategist & marketing advisor with 14 years of experience. 6 ventures founded, 3 exits, Red Dot Award and German Design Award winner. Works 1:1 with decision-makers — no agency, no workshops that lead nowhere.

LinkedIn →

Marketing Strategy Consulting. What It Can Deliver — and What It Cannot.